Looking for the funniest pie puns to sweeten your feed and serve some sassy slice-of-life humor?
These freshly baked puns are piping hot for 2025—perfect for Instagram captions, birthday cards, bakery signs, or just cracking up your group chats.
Whether you’re a seasoned pie-lover or just here for the flaky wordplay, these crust-worthy quips will have everyone saying “You’re the apple of my pie!”
Get ready to laugh till you crumble—this is pun perfection. 🥧💬
🎃 Pumpkin Pie Puns
- 🎃 You’re the pumpkin to my spice, and I can’t pie-n without you
- 🎃 You’re sweeter than whipped cream on a pumpkin pie
- 🎃 Let’s carve out some time for just us and a pie
- 🎃 I must be falling for you like leaves in October
- 🎃 Our love is as warm as fresh pumpkin pie
- 🎃 I’m falling for you faster than leaves and pumpkin sales
- 🎃 You’re the treat in my trick-or-treat pie
- 🎃 I’m nuts about your pumpkin-filled smile
- 🎃 Let’s spice things up like a good pie should
- 🎃 Are you made of pumpkins? Because I’m totally pie-struck
- 🎃 You give me pumpkin to talk about
- 🎃 Our love is seasonal, but I want it all year like pumpkin pie
- 🎃 I find you a-peeling like a pie crust
- 🎃 You’re the pie to my fork, the spice to my latte
- 🎃 You had me at pumpkin
😂 Funny Pie Puns
- 😂 Pie like you berry much
- 😂 I crust you with all my heart
- 😂 Life’s short, eat pie and flirt
- 😂 I’m not crusty, I’m just full of fillings
- 😂 You’re the filling to my pie chart
- 😂 Don’t be flaky unless you’re a pie
- 😂 I’m in a committed crustationship
- 😂 Let’s roll together like pie dough
- 😂 You’re as sweet as pie, and twice as messy
- 😂 I can’t be tart with you around
- 😂 You had me at dessert
- 😂 I dough-n’t know what I’d do without you
- 😂 You’re my upper crust
- 😂 I’m not cherry-picking, you’re just the best
- 😂 I’m falling in loaf with your crusty charm
🍎 Apple Pie Puns
- 🍎 You’re the apple to my pie
- 🍎 Let’s make this a sweet slice of love
- 🍎 I’d pick you from any orchard
- 🍎 You make my heart crumble
- 🍎 You’re as American as apple pie and just as sweet
- 🍎 Let’s bake something special together
- 🍎 I’m apple-solutely into you
- 🍎 Our love is warm, just like a fresh pie
- 🍎 Apple-y ever after sounds nice with you
- 🍎 I can’t resist your golden crust
- 🍎 You’re the core of my dessert dreams
- 🍎 You’re my main squeeze in the pie world
- 🍎 You fill me with delight like cinnamon in pie
- 🍎 Let’s not make this a crumby love story
- 🍎 Granny Smith ain’t got nothin’ on you
😏 Pie Puns One Liners
- 😏 I’m crust-fallen without you
- 😏 You’re a slice above the rest
- 😏 Don’t dessert me
- 😏 I’m pie-ning for you
- 😏 Flaky on the outside, sweet on the inside
- 😏 You’re my sweetie pie
- 😏 I like you berry much
- 😏 Pie love you more than cake
- 😏 Just roll with it
- 😏 You’re un-crust-believable
- 😏 We go together like pie and whipped cream
- 😏 Love you to pieces (of pie)
- 😏 You’re the cherry on top of my pie
- 😏 I’m sweet on you
- 😏 Our love is perfectly baked
⏱️ Short Pie Puns
- ⏱️ Pie love you
- ⏱️ Stay flaky
- ⏱️ Crust me
- ⏱️ Slice, slice baby
- ⏱️ Just pie it
- ⏱️ I dough
- ⏱️ Let’s roll
- ⏱️ Pie happens
- ⏱️ You’re so filling
- ⏱️ Sweetie pie
- ⏱️ Love at first bite
- ⏱️ Eat dessert first
- ⏱️ Whisk it all
- ⏱️ Don’t crust anyone else
🦃 Thanksgiving Pie Puns
- 🦃 I’m thankful you’re in my pie chart
- 🦃 My gratitude is as full as my pie plate
- 🦃 You’re the sweetest part of Thanksgiving
- 🦃 Gobble me up like your favorite slice
- 🦃 Let’s give thanks for this sweet connection
- 🦃 My love is as strong as grandma’s crust
- 🦃 Pass the love and the pie
- 🦃 Pie-thankful we met
- 🦃 You’re the reason I’m thankful this year
- 🦃 Giving thanks never tasted so sweet
- 🦃 You’re the marshmallow to my sweet potato pie
- 🦃 I’m grateful for your flaky heart
- 🦃 Let’s carve out time for pie and cuddles
- 🦃 Stuffed with love and dessert
- 🦃 Sweet thanks and sweeter pies
🥧 Pie Puns for Thanksgiving
- 🥧 You complete my Thanksgiving table
- 🥧 I’m thankful you’re my sweetie pie
- 🥧 Thanksgiving is better with your slice of love
- 🥧 You make my heart rise like warm pie
- 🥧 Grateful for this crusty connection
- 🥧 Let’s bake thankfulness into every moment
- 🥧 You’re my dessert destiny
- 🥧 Full plate, full heart, full of pie
- 🥧 Every thankful bite reminds me of you
- 🥧 Love you more than second helpings
- 🥧 Let’s toast to pie and passion
- 🥧 I’m stuffed with sweet feelings for you
- 🥧 Love like this needs no leftovers
- 🥧 You make me feel like Thanksgiving every day
- 🥧 Gravy? Nah, I’m thankful for your sweetness
🍈 Key Lime Pie Puns
- 🍈 You’re my main squeeze
- 🍈 Lime all yours
- 🍈 Don’t tart without me
- 🍈 You zest up my life
- 🍈 I’m tangy for you
- 🍈 Love you to the lime and back
- 🍈 Our love is zesty and sweet
- 🍈 You key my heart
- 🍈 Let’s whip it like pie topping
- 🍈 You’re the lime of my life
- 🍈 Tart but true
- 🍈 That’s how the pie crumbles
- 🍈 You’ve got the key to my dessert
- 🍈 Let’s bake a citrusy future
- 🍈 Squeeze me tight like pie crust
🌰 Pecan Pie Puns
- 🌰 You’re nuts if you think I’m not in love
- 🌰 We’re a pecan-perfect match
- 🌰 Love you like pecan pie—deep and rich
- 🌰 Cracked for you like a pecan shell
- 🌰 You make my heart gooey
- 🌰 My feelings are nuttin’ but love
- 🌰 You’re my southern comfort pie
- 🌰 Sweet and nutty—just like us
- 🌰 Let’s stick together like syrup and pecans
- 🌰 You bring out my nuttiest side
- 🌰 You’ve got me stuck like pecans in syrup
- 🌰 Our love is golden brown and full of crunch
- 🌰 Life’s sweeter with you in the mix
- 🌰 You’re my sugar and spice
📝 Conclusion
Whether you’re serving up laughs at Thanksgiving or looking for the perfect pun to impress your crush, pie puns are always a sweet idea.
From short zingers to flavor-specific wordplay, these puns are as satisfying as your favorite dessert.
So next time life gives you lemons—or key limes—bake a pun and make someone smile!
